Ep. 423 - EVERYONE is Talking About John Mateer

John Mateer has been the talk of the college football world for the last 6-9 days.

Lee and Grant discuss Mateer’s viral offseason moments and the recent reports about his thumb injury, throwing motion, mechanics, and offseason work to become a better passer. 

Plus the guys talk about OU moving its 2026 season opener against UTEP to Friday night, the NCAA’s proposed five-year eligibility model, and a few corrections from last week’s episode!

We save some World Cup talk for the end if that interests you.

Chapters/Timecodes

00:00 — Opening Take -- John Mateer’s big week: viral squat video, Manning Passing Academy and throwing mechanics
06:16 — Show correction: 31 personnel vs. 13 personnel
07:19 — Lee and Grant reintroduce themselves to new YouTube viewers
10:07 — West of Everest’s role in the OU football podcast ecosystem
12:29 — Grant’s reaction to all the John Mateer offseason attention
14:52 — Mateer’s viral front squat video and Manning Passing Academy look
19:50 — Breaking down Mateer’s throwing motion and release
20:08 — Why Mateer still looks like a natural three-quarter arm passer
21:15 — Comparing pre-injury and post-injury Mateer
24:01 — Watching Mateer’s Oklahoma debut against Illinois State
24:45 — Mateer’s arm angle, release style and natural throwing motion
25:03 — Mateer’s arm strength and the Josh Allen comparison
25:49 — Why changing quarterback mechanics takes time and thousands of reps
28:15 — Evaluating recent Manning Passing Academy clips
31:09 — Reviewing more Mateer throws from Manning Passing Academy
36:41 — Oklahoma’s 2026 season opener against UTEP moves to Friday night
37:02 — Roger Denny’s statement on the Friday night opener
37:51 — Why the Friday opener gives OU an extra day before Michigan
41:04 — Looking back at OU’s previous Friday night opener against Temple
41:20 — Why West of Everest sounded the alarm early on the 2024 OU offense
43:25 — Comparing the Temple opener to Mateer’s Illinois State debut
44:33 — What elite Oklahoma offenses used to look like against overmatched opponents
45:58 — NCAA’s proposed five-year eligibility model
47:06 — How the new age-based eligibility clock would work
48:33 — Why the proposed model could change redshirts and record books
52:52 — Can the NCAA actually enforce new eligibility rules after recent lawsuits?
54:02 — Collective bargaining, unions and the future of college athlete rules
57:02 — Show corrections segment begins
57:52 — Revisiting the Kip Lewis linebacker discussion
01:00:00 — Curtis Lofton correction: best OU linebacker since Rufus Alexander?
01:01:16 — Minnesota football and paying players in the 1980s
01:04:29 — Happy Fourth of July and World Cup talk
01:04:48 — Why the USMNT in the World Cup still feels like a big deal
01:06:02 — Folarin Balogun, red cards and FIFA decision-making
01:10:19 — Soccer replay debate: slow motion, red cards and rule interpretation
01:13:01 — Comparing replay in soccer to replay in football
01:16:17 — Should red cards punish intent, danger or outcome?
01:22:41 — What soccer might look like with a few rule tweaks
01:25:19 — Closing thoughts and where to follow West of Everest

Follow West of Everest

Subscribe to the West of Everest YouTube channel for full episodes, clips and Shorts. Follow the show on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, and please leave a five-star rating and review if you enjoy the podcast.

Follow West of Everest on X, Instagram and Facebook.

#OklahomaFootball #OUFootball #Sooners #JohnMateer #CollegeFootball #WestOfEverest