The Man Who Led 100+ CROs (Even OpenAI's) | John McMahon - 5x Post-IPO CRO / The GOAT

John McMahon, a five-time public company CRO whose team at PTC created MEDDIC, joins Sam Jacobs, AJ Bruno, and Asad Zaman on building enterprise sales teams that last. Topics include the PTC lineage that has produced over 100 CROs, including OpenAI's Dali Rajic, why he hires on characteristics over resumes, whether a CRO who never carried a bag can lead, and how first-time CROs should work with their CEO. Plus, capped commissions at Anthropic, why AI makes lazy reps lazier, what conversational intelligence tools miss in deal qualification, and quick takes on Dali, Carlos at Harness, Dev Ittycheria, and Chris at Cognition.

Key Takeaways:

- Hire on characteristics, not resumes. John sorts candidates by skills, knowledge, experience and characteristics, and the last one is the hardest to teach: "I've always hired on characteristics. So I'll take someone with less experience but great characteristics." He looks for intelligence, drive, coachability, adaptability and integrity, because when a hire fails, "it's always a character flaw."
- Don't take the CRO seat before you're ready. John once refused a promotion Dali pushed him for: "I told him, I'm not gonna do that to you because you're not ready… you're gonna fail. Your ego's not gonna be able to take it." For John, readiness comes down to whether you can recruit, coach, and lead people who actually want to follow you.
- Talk to the CEO as a partner. Plenty of first-time CROs hold the C-level title without acting like the CEO's peer, and John coaches them to speak up: "You're the CRO. You have a fiduciary responsibility. Tell the CEO specifically what you think is wrong with the business." Blaming revenue problems on the product "is a non-starter," so come with a solution and talk like a business owner.
- AI hasn't changed the methodology. John sees AI mostly as a research tool, and "it makes the really good sales reps better, and it makes the lazy sales reps lazier." He is just as blunt about conversational intelligence: "All they're doing is verifying that something was said, but there's no true qualification." Qualifying still means knowing whether you're talking to a champion, a coach, or the enemy.

Connect with the Hosts & Guests:

Host: Sam Jacobs, CEO at Pavilion - https://www.linkedin.com/in/samfjacobs/
Host: AJ Bruno, CEO at QuotaPath - https://www.linkedin.com/in/ajbruno3/
Host: Asad Zaman, CEO at STA - https://www.linkedin.com/in/azaman1/
Guest: John McMahon, 5x Public Company CRO - https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnmcmahon1/

Topline is more than a podcast:

Subscribe to Topline Newsletter: https://toplinemedia.substack.com/
Check us out on YouTube for the #1 video podcast for founders, operators, and investors in B2B tech: https://www.youtube.com/@TOPLINE-Media
Join the free Topline Slack channel to connect with 600+ revenue leaders to keep the conversation going beyond the podcast: https://www.joinpavilion.com/topline-slack

Chapters:
00:00 Introducing John McMahon
02:18 The PTC Sales Leadership Tree
07:20 Hiring on Characteristics, Not Resumes
12:10 Should a CRO Have Carried a Bag?
16:50 Capped Commissions vs. Equity Upside
19:05 When Are You Ready to Be CRO?
22:56 How CROs Should Evaluate the CEO
34:52 AI and Sales Methodology
38:10 AI Call Tools Don't Qualify Deals
40:52 MEDDIC and Bigger Buying Groups
42:51 The Art and Science of Selling
48:47 Coaching Mark Roberge at HubSpot
59:31 Managing Heads Like a Bond Portfolio
01:03:42 Hiring Batting Average and Ramp Time
01:09:40 Rapid Fire: Dali, Carlos, Dev, Chris