Skip to content
Opens in a new window
Did Paris Win the Bingham Cup Unfairly? Les Gaillards Explain | Ep 67
16 November 2026

Did Paris Win the Bingham Cup Unfairly? Les Gaillards Explain | Ep 67

The Gay Rugby Podcast

About

Les Gaillards Paris Rugby Club made history by winning the world's biggest LGBTQ+ rugby tournament, but their victory sparked controversy over one unusual rule: they weren't allowed to contest scrums.In this episode of The Gay Rugby Podcast, Jack and Ozzie sit down with Vianney Mosser from Les Gaillards, France's first LGBTQ+ inclusive rugby club, during the 2026 Bingham Cup in Brisbane, Australia.Les Gaillards won the 2024 Bingham Cup in Rome, defeating the Sydney Convicts in the championship final. But some rugby players and fans questioned whether the French team's uncontested scrum rule gave them an unfair competitive advantage.Vianney explains why Les Gaillards chose to prioritize inclusivity, allowing men, women, and transgender rugby players to participate together. Because of restrictions under the French rugby federation and their alternative insurance arrangement, the team was prohibited from contesting scrums. As a result, Les Gaillards played with just 14 players against teams of 15, including during their historic Bingham Cup victory.We discuss whether uncontested scrums create a tactical advantage in rugby union, how insurance regulations affect inclusive rugby clubs, and whether the rules should change to better accommodate LGBTQ+ athletes.Beyond the Bingham Cup controversy, we explore the history of gay rugby in France, homophobia in rugby, transgender inclusion in sports, the importance of safe spaces for LGBTQ+ athletes, and how Les Gaillards is working to make rugby accessible to everyone.And of course, we find out that the French rugby players might be doing a little more scrummaging behind closed doors than they do on the pitch!What do you think? Was Les Gaillards' 2024 Bingham Cup victory fair, or do uncontested scrums create an unfair advantage? Let us know in the comments!