Sharlie of Payette Lake & Old Idaho Penitentiary: Folklore and Hauntings of Idaho

Welcome to Tenebrous Tingles! This week, Eve and Zandi dive into Idaho’s spookiest legends, exploring Sharlie, the mysterious lake monster of Payette Lake, and the haunted history of the Old Idaho Penitentiary. Hear tales of sightings, paranormal encounters, and the eerie stories that have captivated locals for decades.

Whether you love cryptids, haunted prisons, or local folklore, this episode is full of chilling stories and fascinating history.

Next time, we’ll be heading to Illinois and will have a special guest—don’t miss it!

✉️ Contact us: tenebrous.tingles@gmail.com

💖 Support the show on Patreon: tenebroustingles

Contact us at: Tenebrous.Tingles@gmail.com