Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this podcast
Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!
Top CategoriesView all
02 December 2023
This week, in McLean, Virginia, a frantic 911 call, from an out of state boyfriend starts an investigation, where a mother, and her adult daughter are found dead, in the same house. What initially looks like a standard murder/suicide, turns into a crazy plot, involving some wild staging, and very in...
#443 - Writing Your Murder Script - Lempster, New Hampshire
30 November 2023
This week, in Lempster, New Hampshire, twisted relationships, and misplaced anger lead to someone, mysteriously disappearing, off the face of the earth. Detectives eventually find a treasure trove of evidence, including part of a skeleton, and some very detailed notebooks, that tell a disturbing sto...
#442 - The Social Media Loving Cannibal - Joppatowne, Maryland
25 November 2023
This week, in Joppatowne, Maryland, a college student begins to display some very strange, and concerning behavior, violently attacking a fellow student, and making some of the weirdest social media posts, ever. This escalates quickly, and before you know it, someone is dead. Not only dead, but dism...
#441 - Bashed, Slashed & Scattered - Fillmore, Utah
23 November 2023
This week, in Fillmore, Utah, a young lady, who is happy to stand up for herself when needed, goes on a trip, and ends up hitchhiking, and is never seen alive, again. When she is finally found, it's as awful of a scene as someone could imagine, with many parts missing. When detectives get a tip from...
#440 - A Character Of Evil - Airdrie, Alberta, Canada
18 November 2023
This week, in Airdrie, Alberta, Canada, a strange hatred, and need of revenge boils inside of a very odd man, for years. It starts out as a nationwide mystery, but ends up as one of the most brutal & disturbing set of murders in Canadian history, and the whole thing was solved by an accidental p...
#439 - Did The Dog Do It? - Dillsboro, Indiana
16 November 2023
This week, in Dillsboro, Indiana, when a very tough, but gentle man is allegedly murdered... by his dog, police are suspicious of the story. Detectives are even more suspicious, when they find a coffin sized box, on the property, that the man's wife won't let police search. The question is, was he a...
#438 - An Officer & Three Maniacs - Biloxi, Mississippi
11 November 2023
This week, in Biloxi, Mississippi, when a rough teenaged divorcee/bartender/dancer gets angry about her relationship with a older man not working out, she forms a team, including another teenager, and a man, who lives in his car. This leads to a nightmare of a night, that ends with someone's head, a...
#437 - Sex, Greed & Vice Principals - Toms River Township, New Jersey
09 November 2023
This week, in Toms River Township, New Jersey, a wild & cruel conspiracy is the only explanation when one member of an important, well liked local couple is brutally killed. An affair with the local high school vice principal is uncovered, along with many insurance policies, and a phone record t...
#436 - The Unraveling Of A Psychopath - Windsor, Wisconsin
03 November 2023
This week, in Windsor, Wisconsin, it's a huge mystery, when a happy, and successful couple seem to disappear into thin air. While their seemingly clean cut, well adjusted young adult children beg the police for help, detectives use a jealous girlfriend's access to her boyfriend's social media accoun...
#435 - Laughing, Torture & Lies - Gans, Oklahoma
02 November 2023
This week, in Gans , Oklahoma, a woman, with a strange past, decides to take matters into her own hands when she believes that her son's ex girlfriend is setting him up to be busted by the cops, or even killed, so a series of events is set in motion that includes as bad as a murder as you can imagin...