There have been countless versions of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol—from plays and
films to Muppets and animated cartoons. And just when you think there couldn’t possibly be another unique interpretation of this classic story, think again.
Ebenezer, directed by Ti West and starring Johnny Depp, takes a deeper look into the life of
Ebenezer Scrooge and the people who shaped him. And that is what sets this version apart.
We all know the story. Ebenezer Scrooge is a wealthy, crotchety miser who considers Christmas a humbug and charity a waste of money. He mistreats his employee Bob Cratchit, played by Rupert Grint, and rejects his nephew Fred’s attempts to connect with him. After the death of his equally greedy business partner, Jacob Marley, played by Ian McKellen, Scrooge becomes even more hardened.
On Christmas Eve, Marley’s ghost appears, burdened by the chains of his past, warning Scrooge that he faces the same fate unless he changes. Three spirits then guide him through his past, present, and future, ultimately leading to his redemption.
Johnny Depp delivers a convincing performance as Scrooge. He doesn’t overplay the character, instead allowing glimpses of humanity to emerge early on. His expressions of terror, sadness, anger, and eventual joy capture the complexity of Dickens’ famous miser.
Ian McKellen shines as Jacob Marley, both in life and as a terrifying ghost. Rupert Grint is
perfectly cast as the timid, hardworking Bob Cratchit, struggling to provide for his family.
The Ghosts of Christmas Past and Christmas Yet to Come are frightening, forcing Scrooge to
confront uncomfortable truths. But the standout performance belongs to Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present. His appreciation of life’s pleasures contrasts beautifully with the pain of knowing his own life is ending. His struggle against the children Ignorance and Want is particularly moving.
What makes this adaptation special is its exploration of Scrooge’s past. We see him bullied at school, growing up with an alcoholic father, losing his love Belle, who becomes a successful writer, and witnessing the fate of his former employer, Mr. Fezziwig.
Interestingly, the film gives less attention to Bob Cratchit and Tiny Tim. But I actually appreciated that choice. Other adaptations have focused heavily on the Cratchit family. This one concentrates on Scrooge himself. For perhaps the first time, I found myself genuinely feeling sorry for Ebenezer, understanding how his difficult life shaped the bitter man he became. The gloomy London settings and atmospheric lighting beautifully capture Dickens’ world.
This is pure Dickensian storytelling, and I suspect that if Charles Dickens were alive today he might consider this adaptation closest to his original vision.
For the KSQD Film Gang: Molly Sullivan.