Skip to content
Opens in a new window
No disguise: Cayman Islands Court sends redemption claim to Hong Kong arbitration
The decision in brief
Practical takeaways
Comment
05 November 2026

No disguise: Cayman Islands Court sends redemption claim to Hong Kong arbitration The decision in brief Practical takeaways Comment

Exploring Offshore Litigation

About
In a recent decision of the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands, a US$87 million claim for "specific performance" of share redemption rights was found to be what it really was: a claim for money, caught by a Hong Kong arbitration clause. The action was stayed.

Investors and companies in Asia involved in redemption disputes should take note. Calling a payment claim something else will not take it outside an arbitration agreement, and wording that lets parties go to court for certain relief may be far narrower than it looks.

In TB MGMT LLC v Taibang Biological Ltd, the Plaintiffs were holding vehicles through which Joseph Chow held shares in Taibang, a Cayman Islands company. Mr Chow was removed as chairman in December 2024. The Plaintiffs said this was without "Cause", which entitled them to have Taibang redeem their shares at fair market value. Taibang said he was removed for Cause, so no redemption right arose.

The shareholders' agreement provided for HKIAC arbitration in Hong Kong. It also allowed either party to seek "an injunction, temporary restraining order or other equitable relief" in court. The Plaintiffs relied on that wording and sued in the Grand Court for specific performance of the redemption provisions, asking to be paid over US$87 million. Three days later, Taibang began the arbitration. It then applied to stay the Cayman Islands action.

Justice Doyle granted a mandatory stay under section 4 of the Foreign Arbitral Awards Enforcement Act. The real dispute was whether Mr Chow had been removed without Cause. The specific performance claim was held to be "entirely artificial and a mere device" to get around the arbitration clause. Even if it had been genuine, the court-relief wording only covered interim relief "enjoining" a breach, not a full claim to be paid.

An argument that Taibang had waived arbitration also failed, and the judge said he would have granted a discretionary stay in any event. The Plaintiffs, whose attorneys had come off the record, did not attend the hearing and were ordered to pay Taibang's costs.

Redemption and put rights in Cayman Islands companies backed by PRC and Hong Kong investors are often paired with an arbitration clause in the shareholders' agreement. For anyone holding or facing those rights, five points stand out.

1.

Substance wins over form: The Court will look past the label to the real dispute. If what you are really after is the redemption price, assume the claim will be treated as a claim for money, however you plead it.

2.

Read the court-relief wording closely: Here, a right to seek "an injunction, temporary restraining order or other equitable relief" in court was confined to genuine interim relief. It did not open the door to a full payment claim. Nor did the clause heading, "Specific Performance", help, because the agreement said headings were not to be used in interpreting it. If you want redemption claims heard in court, say so clearly.

3.

The articles may not offer a way out: The redemption rights and the definition of Cause appeared in both the shareholders' agreement and the articles, but only the shareholders' agreement had an arbitration clause. The Plaintiffs argued that their claims under the articles did not need to be arbitrated. That did not help them, because the substance of the dispute still fell within the arbitration agreement. The simplest fix at the drafting stage is to make the dispute resolution provisions match.

4.

Do not go quiet: A company can only appear in the Grand Court through an attorney. If its attorneys come off the record and it does nothing, the Court can carry on without it and order it to pay costs. The judge described the approach taken by the Plaintiffs as an "unhelpful and potentially abusive strategy of non-engagement" and remarked that burying your head in the sand "is rarely, if ever, a good litigation tactic".

5.

Move quickly: Taibang started its arbitration three days after the writ was issued and applied for a stay before fili...