Skip to content
Opens in a new window
Anchors away: BVI Court of Appeal rejects improper use of anchor defendants
Background
A high bar for appellate interference
The anchor must hold
Mere incorporation in the BVI is not sufficient
Failure to give full and frank disclosure
Key takeaways
03 November 2026

Anchors away: BVI Court of Appeal rejects improper use of anchor defendants Background A high bar for appellate interference The anchor must hold Mere incorporation in the BVI is not sufficient Failure to give full and frank disclosure Key takeaways

Exploring Offshore Litigation

About
In the recent decision of BTA Bank v Mamesh, the BVI Court of Appeal rejected BTA Bank's attempt to use restored BVI shell companies as anchor defendants for an alleged US$230 million fraud claim against foreign defendants, and upheld the order setting aside permission to serve out.

The decision, which turns largely on appellate deference to the judge's evaluative assessment, illustrates that a claimant relying on the necessary or proper party gateway must show that there is genuine utility in the BVI Court trying the claim against the anchor defendant(s). It is also a stark reminder of the consequences of failing to give full and frank disclosure on an ex parte service out application.

BTA Bank, a Kazakhstani financial institution, alleges that it was the victim of a fraudulent scheme orchestrated by its former chairman and employees between around 2005 and 2009, involving around 100 letters of credit to fund purported commodity sales, with the money diverted through offshore special purpose vehicles and on to foreign entities. Some of those vehicles were BVI companies.

In September 2021, the bank issued proceedings against 54 defendants in the BVI after restoring eight BVI companies that had been struck off and dissolved years earlier. In May 2022, it obtained permission ex parte to serve the foreign defendants out of the jurisdiction, relying principally on the necessary or proper party gateway, with the BVI companies as the anchor defendants. The BVI companies never engaged with the claim and were struck off again in 2022 and 2023.

Several foreign defendants applied to set aside the permission to serve out and Justice Wallbank granted the application. He found that (i) even assuming there was a real issue between the bank and the BVI companies, it was not reasonable for the court to try it; (ii) the company gateway was not engaged; (iii) the BVI was not clearly or distinctly the appropriate forum; and (iv) the bank had breached its duty of full and frank disclosure in ways that were not innocent.

The bank appealed and argued that the judge was wrong in (i) finding that there was no real issue that was reasonable for the court to try; (ii) deciding that the BVI was not clearly and distinctly the most appropriate forum; and (iii) concluding that there was a breach of the duty of full and frank disclosure. The Court of Appeal dismissed the bank's appeal on all grounds.

As a starting point, the Court confirmed that, as an appellate court, it ought to be slow to interfere with the judge's decision where the appeal involves an evaluation of the facts and law and exercise of discretion. Applying the principles set out in its decision in Dufour v Helenair and the English Court of Appeal's decision in Re Sprintroom, the Court reaffirmed that it would only interfere if the judge's decision could be shown to be wrong by reason of some identifiable flaw in his treatment of the question to be decided, such as a gap in logic, a lack of consistency or a failure to consider a material factor, which undermines the cogency of the conclusion.

In recognising the appellate court's deference to the evaluative assessment undertaken in the court below, the Court also gave weight to the fact that the same judge had heard both the ex parte application and the set-aside applications.

The Court of Appeal disagreed with the bank's argument that the judge had misapplied the gateway. Relying on the Privy Council's decisions in Nilon Ltd v Royal Westminster Investments SA and Altimo Holdings and Investment Ltd v Kyrgyz Mobile Tel Ltd, the Court restated the principles, including the following, applicable to the necessary or proper party gateway:

Caution must always be exercised in bringing foreign defendants within the jurisdiction under that gateway, and it should never become the practice to bring them in as a matter of course on the ground that the only alternative requires more than one suit in more than one jurisdiction.

The fact that an anchor d...