12 November 2026
AI before the Courts: recent developments in the offshore world What happened? Why smaller jurisdictions are different Using AI responsibly to keep costs down Conclusion
Exploring Offshore Litigation
About
Recent decisions of the Jersey and Guernsey courts confirm that generative AI can have a place in litigation, but only where its output is verified and the person relying on it takes personal responsibility for what goes before the court.
Both cases involved a litigant in person who had leaned on AI to prepare court documents.
Jersey: In Golden Sphinx v Itkin, the Master of the Royal Court found that the defendant had been using AI and that his errors were hallucinations. He cited a non-existent Jersey statute on prescription (limitation), two non-existent Jersey judgments and a genuine trust judgment for a human rights proposition it did not support. His submissions and affidavits ran to over 2,200 pages.
Guernsey: In States of Guernsey v Ogier, the Royal Court noted that the respondent had relied on AI to prepare lengthy written submissions, and reminded all parties, represented or not, of their duty to ensure that cases cited are genuine and support the proposition advanced.
Similar issues have arisen in other offshore jurisdictions. Our earlier blog, Cayman Court issues warning on AI use in legal filings, discusses a recent Cayman Islands decision on the same theme.
There is a particular reason for caution in offshore litigation. As the Jersey Court observed, there is an extremely limited amount of material freely available online about Jersey law, and the same broadly tends to be true in smaller jurisdictions generally. Generic AI tools trained largely on material from larger jurisdictions may fill the gaps with seemingly plausible but wrong answers, or answers based on English or even American law.
In an increasingly competitive market, clients reasonably expect their lawyers to use technology to work efficiently and keep costs low. Where used, the following may be helpful:
AI should assist, not author. A case should start from real law and evidence. AI can then help to develop and express it, but the legal analysis must be the lawyer's own.
Everything is verified. Every authority, quotation and factual statement should be checked against authoritative sources before it is relied on.
Supervision is non-negotiable. AI output should be reviewed as carefully as a junior team member's first draft.
The correct tools are used. Many leading firms use in-house or bespoke legal AI tools rather than free generic chatbots, which helps to avoid some of their known pitfalls and protect confidentiality.
Be candid with the court. Where the rules or the court require AI use to be disclosed, it should be disclosed. Some courts are moving towards requiring it proactively.
Shorter is often better. AI makes it easy to produce volume. Courts are alive to being flooded with material, and concise, focused submissions are more persuasive and cost effective.
It is simply unrealistic to expect parties not to use AI at all. The real question for clients is not whether their lawyers use AI, but how. Clear boundaries, rigorous verification and candour with the court allow AI to deliver genuine savings without compromising standards. While jurisdiction-specific guidance is key (whether in the form of local Practice Directions, judgments or otherwise), best practice from across the common law world can and should inform the conduct of offshore litigation generally.
Harneys does not practise Guernsey law.
This article is based on a longer piece by the author submitted to the Jersey and Guernsey Law Review.
Both cases involved a litigant in person who had leaned on AI to prepare court documents.
Jersey: In Golden Sphinx v Itkin, the Master of the Royal Court found that the defendant had been using AI and that his errors were hallucinations. He cited a non-existent Jersey statute on prescription (limitation), two non-existent Jersey judgments and a genuine trust judgment for a human rights proposition it did not support. His submissions and affidavits ran to over 2,200 pages.
Guernsey: In States of Guernsey v Ogier, the Royal Court noted that the respondent had relied on AI to prepare lengthy written submissions, and reminded all parties, represented or not, of their duty to ensure that cases cited are genuine and support the proposition advanced.
Similar issues have arisen in other offshore jurisdictions. Our earlier blog, Cayman Court issues warning on AI use in legal filings, discusses a recent Cayman Islands decision on the same theme.
There is a particular reason for caution in offshore litigation. As the Jersey Court observed, there is an extremely limited amount of material freely available online about Jersey law, and the same broadly tends to be true in smaller jurisdictions generally. Generic AI tools trained largely on material from larger jurisdictions may fill the gaps with seemingly plausible but wrong answers, or answers based on English or even American law.
In an increasingly competitive market, clients reasonably expect their lawyers to use technology to work efficiently and keep costs low. Where used, the following may be helpful:
AI should assist, not author. A case should start from real law and evidence. AI can then help to develop and express it, but the legal analysis must be the lawyer's own.
Everything is verified. Every authority, quotation and factual statement should be checked against authoritative sources before it is relied on.
Supervision is non-negotiable. AI output should be reviewed as carefully as a junior team member's first draft.
The correct tools are used. Many leading firms use in-house or bespoke legal AI tools rather than free generic chatbots, which helps to avoid some of their known pitfalls and protect confidentiality.
Be candid with the court. Where the rules or the court require AI use to be disclosed, it should be disclosed. Some courts are moving towards requiring it proactively.
Shorter is often better. AI makes it easy to produce volume. Courts are alive to being flooded with material, and concise, focused submissions are more persuasive and cost effective.
It is simply unrealistic to expect parties not to use AI at all. The real question for clients is not whether their lawyers use AI, but how. Clear boundaries, rigorous verification and candour with the court allow AI to deliver genuine savings without compromising standards. While jurisdiction-specific guidance is key (whether in the form of local Practice Directions, judgments or otherwise), best practice from across the common law world can and should inform the conduct of offshore litigation generally.
Harneys does not practise Guernsey law.
This article is based on a longer piece by the author submitted to the Jersey and Guernsey Law Review.