Was Athens' Golden Age Really Golden? | Pericles, Democracy & Empire
Was ancient Athens truly the birthplace of democracy and civilization or was its famous Golden Age built on conquest, inequality, and imperial power?
When we think of Pericles and the Golden Age of Athens, we imagine the Parthenon, Socrates, Greek tragedy, extraordinary art, and the birth of Western democracy.
But behind this remarkable cultural flourishing lies a far more complicated story.
How democratic was Athens really? Who paid for its greatness? And was Pericles a visionary statesman—or a brilliant demagogue?
In this special Classical Wisdom event, host Anya Leonard welcomes two distinguished scholars of ancient Greece:
Paul Cartledge, historian of ancient Greek democracy and author of Pericles: Statesman, Demagogue, Eccentric, and Armand D'Angour, Oxford classicist and author of Socrates in Love: The Making of a Philosopher.
Together, they challenge the traditional image of fifth-century BCE Athens and explore the extraordinary achievements—and troubling contradictions—of its most celebrated political leader.
Pericles was born into an aristocratic family, yet became a champion of Athenian democracy. He helped expand political participation while simultaneously defending an empire that demanded tribute and obedience from its allies.
Under his leadership, Athens built the Parthenon, became a center of art and intellectual life, and developed a political culture built around public debate and persuasion.
But its prosperity came at a cost.
The Athenian Empire exerted power over other Greek city-states, while women, enslaved people, and noncitizens remained excluded from democratic decision-making.
The discussion also examines the remarkable Aspasia of Miletus, Pericles' influential partner, whose intellectual and social position challenges our assumptions about women in classical Athens.
And then there is the question of war.
Did Pericles' policies make the Peloponnesian War inevitable? Was he right to confront Sparta, or did his commitment to Athenian supremacy help bring about the destruction of the world he had helped create?
Drawing on Thucydides, Plutarch, ancient political institutions, and modern historical scholarship, Paul and Armand explore how charisma, rhetoric, ambition, and imperial power shaped Athenian democracy.
The result is a fascinating reconsideration of one of history's most influential—and most contradictory—civilizations.
Was the Golden Age of Athens a triumph of democracy, or a warning about what happens when democracy becomes an empire?
Timestamps:
00:00 Pericles and the myth of the Golden Age
02:11 Meet Paul Cartledge and Armand D'Angour
04:14 Who was Pericles?
10:49 What made Athens' Golden Age?
15:04 Statesman or demagogue?
21:02 Why was Pericles controversial?
25:26 Ostracism and democratic accountability
28:01 Can democracy coexist with empire?
35:43 Pericles and imperial power
48:01 Aspasia: the woman behind Pericles
01:05:03 Athenian identity and citizenship
01:11:00 What caused the Peloponnesian War?
01:21:02 Audience Q&A
01:23:00 The plague and Pericles' downfall
01:35:00 Democracy, duty, and civic life
01:49:00 Final reflections
What Do You Think?
Can a society truly call itself democratic while ruling over others?
And do you think Pericles deserves his reputation as one of history's greatest statesmen?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Explore Classical Wisdom's free newsletter, in-depth articles, events, and resources: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/
👉 Subscribe to Classical Wisdom for more conversations about ancient history, Greek philosophy, democracy, mythology, and the ideas that continue to shape our world.
Guests:
Paul Cartledge is a leading historian of ancient Greece and a senior research fellow at Clare College, Cambridge. His work explores Sparta, Athenian democracy, Greek politics, and classical civilization. He is the author of Pericles: Statesman, Demagogue, Eccentric.
Armand D'Angour is Professor of Classics at the University of Oxford and Fellow and Tutor at Jesus College. His research explores ancient Greek culture, philosophy, music, and intellectual history. He is the author of Socrates in Love: The Making of a Philosopher.
About