Opens in a new window
The 22-year Old Rookie Who Broke Tom Seaver, San Diego Padres at New York Mets, May 6, 1972 (Recreation)
18 June 2026

The 22-year Old Rookie Who Broke Tom Seaver, San Diego Padres at New York Mets, May 6, 1972 (Recreation)

Classic Baseball Radio

About

A Saturday game in May can be both an inconsequential checkmark in a season and a game that can be looked back on as a captivating moment in history. 

It’s impossible to look back at 1972 and ignore the first players' strike that disrupted the first two weeks of the season. Spring training was curtailed, and both hitters and pitchers are still struggling with timing in May. 86 games were wiped from the schedules, never to be rescheduled. The Padres will end up playing just 153 games, while the Mets will play 156.

Also looking to find his way in the season is Mets manager, Yogi Berra. Following the sudden passing of Gil Hodges, Berra is finding his feet and beginning to understand the core of the Mets' line-up. It’s an intense spotlight that will shine brightly on him during the 1972 season, as the Mets finish a credible third. That core would head into 1973 ready to claim the National League pennant.

The biggest name in the Mets’ line-up is surely Tom Seaver. He has already posted two 20-win seasons (with 25 wins in 1969 and an on-the-nose 20 wins in 1971) and has a Cy Young to his name. Facing him was seen as a near-automatic loss. Not only that, but his record against the San Diego Padres is even more impressive. In terms of overpowering presence, he’s less Mr Terrific and more Mr Terrifying.

Can the Padres, with rookie pitcher Bill Grief, hurl the ball and swing the bat to find some magic?

Ewan Spence and the Classic Baseball Radio team bring you this recreated radio broadcast from May 6, 1972. This should not be considered a complete or fully accurate historical record. Nevertheless, this is our story of the game.

We thank Retrosheet, Sports Reference, Sports Logos Net, Tom R Audio, and  Crafting The Call.

** Links **

You can find the boxscore here:

https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/NYN/NYN197205060.shtml 

A deep look at the legendary life and career of Tom Seaver, detailing his journey from Fresno, California, to his status as the premier pitcher of his generation.  

https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/tom-seaver/

Why is Tom Seaver the undisputed Franchise player of the Mets, and how does he compare to other players?

https://sny.tv/articles/mets-all-time-team-26-man

Profiling Bill Grief, the durable 6'5" right-handed Texas native who out-duelled Seaver on this afternoon, examining his high-strikeout velocity and post-baseball academic achievements.  

https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/bill-greif/

A tribute to Nate Colbert, the Padres' first true superstar, recounting his 163 franchise home runs and his devotion to youth ministry.

https://www.mlb.com/news/nate-colbert-dies

An account of the sudden passing of Mets manager Gil Hodges just days before the delayed 1972 season, detailing how a grief-stricken clubhouse transitioned under Yogi Berra's leadership.

http://www.centerfieldmaz.com/2020/04/remembering-mets-history-1972-mets.html

Yogi Berra’s 1972 Hall of Fame Induction, including context for his managing duties with the 1972 Mets. 

https://baseballhall.org/discover/inside-pitch/berra-koufax-inducted-amid-star-studded-class-of-1972

The history of the youth-heavy Padres rosters, Buzzie Bavasi’s ticket-promotion strategies, and the physical toll of injuries on the 1972 rotation

https://eastvillagetimes.com/the-history-of-the-san-diego-padres-volume-1-1969-1973/2/.  

A comprehensive breakdown of the historic 13-day player strike in April 1972, analysing how it changed labour relations and shortened the schedule.

https://sabr.org/journal/article/the-strike-of-1972-when-cooperation-failed/

How the 1972 player strike served as Marvin Miller’s first monumental victory, earning players pension increases and third-party salary arbitration.

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/marvin-millers-legacy-and-the-decline-of-labor/