Skip to content
Opens in a new window
DTCP 065 - The Trial of Maggie Pollock
13 October 2026

DTCP 065 - The Trial of Maggie Pollock

Canadian Creepies

About

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!

In a small Ontario community in 1919, a woman named Maggie Pollock found herself at the centre of a controversy that seemed better suited to the 1600s than the 20th century.

Maggie was known around Huron County for her unusual abilities. She claimed to receive visions, communicate with the dead, and help neighbours locate things that had gone missing. To some, she possessed an extraordinary gift. To others, her abilities were something far more suspicious.

But when a farmer paid Maggie to help locate stolen grain, her mysterious reputation landed her in serious legal trouble.

Maggie was charged under a Canadian law that criminalized certain claims of supernatural powers. Her case would become one of the country's most unusual legal battles, raising questions about belief, fraud, superstition, and the treatment of women who didn't quite fit society's expectations.

And the strangest part? The law that helped put Maggie on trial remained on Canada's books until 2018.

In this episode of Down the Crooked Path, Amanda explores the extraordinary true story of Maggie Pollock, the woman known as the Seeress of Blyth, and the Huron County witchcraft case.

Was Maggie a gifted medium, a clever opportunist, or simply a woman whose beliefs put her on the wrong side of an outdated law?

Sometimes the strangest things lurking in Canada's history aren't ghosts or monsters.

Sometimes they're written into the law itself.

🌱 PayYourRent.ca is an Indigenous-led grassroots initiative encouraging settlers to support Indigenous sovereignty, land defenders, and community well-being through ongoing financial contributions.

Put reconciliation into action. Visit PayYourRent.ca and commit to a monthly contribution supporting Indigenous communities, land defenders, and cultural revitalization.

Justice isn’t a moment, it’s a commitment.

 Your next creepy obsession starts here. 

✨ This episode is brought to you by Fable & Frame Creative ✨
Fable & Frame Creative offers Niagara Region portraits and at-home newborn sessions, capturing not just how life looks but how it feels. Because your life isn’t ordinary. It’s a fable, and it deserves to be framed like one.

Thorain Art & Illustration creates darkly whimsical art inspired by vintage Halloween, forgotten fairytales, and strange woodland magic. Find stickers, prints, magnets, keychains, and more on Etsy or at @thorain.draws, and save 10% with code CANADIANCREEPIES.

Manet Macrame & Fibre Arts, created by our researcher Christine, makes spooky handmade macrame, pixel art, epoxy pieces, and Canadian Creepies-inspired books. Save 10% with code CANADIANCREEPIES.

Discover the whimsical world of Yazmin City Arts! This Quebec-based artist creates magical illustrations, charming characters, and fantastical artwork. Explore her creations on her website or shop her Fourthwall store! Follow @yazmincityarts on Instagram and use code CREEPIES10 for 10% off your order while supporting an independent Canadian artist!

🕯️ You can find new episodes of Down the Crooked Path every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts.
Canadian content airs right here on the Canadian Creepies feed, so stay tuned, and stay on the path.

The Secret Is OUT

The Secret Is Out tells the coming-out stories of LGBTQ people —...

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Edited by Kyle McDonnellÂ